Three Layer Chocolate Moist Cake

Okay, so I have a confession to make — and it feels dramatic to finally say it out loud. For the longest time, I simply couldn’t decorate a cake. Like, at all. And before you reassure me, let’s be honest: as someone who cooks and bakes every single week, that’s a bit embarrassing. I could whisk a custard blindfolded, troubleshoot a collapsed loaf, tell you exactly why your cookies spread too much — but hand me a spatula and ask for a smooth cake finish? Disaster. Buttercream ridges, crumbs everywhere, and a finish so lumpy I wanted to cry and throw the whole thing in the bin.

Then came the chaos of my house renovation (because why not schedule life crises in clusters?). In the middle of plaster dust, paint samples and an ongoing hunt for the spirit level, I decided that this — of all times — was when I would finally learn how to properly decorate a cake. Terrible timing, I know. But sometimes determination arrives dressed as madness.

So I did what any desperate baker does: I turned it into a baking boot camp. I tested four different buttercreams — American buttercream, Swiss meringue buttercream, Russian buttercream and Italian meringue buttercream — and let’s just say it was a costly and very interesting experience. But after many trials, lots of swearing under my breath, and a few breakdowns involving an offset spatula, one buttercream came out on top.

Swiss. Meringue. Buttercream.
The holy grail. The answer to smooth cakes. The moment I learnt how to make it properly, something clicked. For the first time in my baking life, I smoothed the sides of a cake and it didn’t fight back. It didn’t crumble. It didn’t tear. It didn’t melt. It just… behaved. I stood there like I’d unlocked a new level in my baker era. I finally felt like a proper baker.

And now that I’ve learnt it — and dare I say, perfected it — it’s only right that I share everything with you. If you’ve ever struggled with decorating a cake, if you’re tired of buttercream that’s too sweet, too gritty or too soft, if you’ve scraped frosting off plates at parties because it’s unbearably sugary, Swiss meringue buttercream is the game-changer you’ve been waiting for.

Before we get to troubleshooting tips and why this buttercream works magic, let’s talk cake — because what’s buttercream without the dream cake underneath?

The chocolate cake recipe I’m pairing with this buttercream comes straight from my cookbook Sugar & Spice — but for today, we’re adapting it from a two-layer cake to a three-layer masterpiece. Because if you’re going to learn cake decorating, you may as well go big or go home. This cake is rich, fudgy and impossibly moist. And before you panic about the coffee in the batter — trust me, you cannot taste it. Coffee simply deepens the chocolate flavour and brings out that luxurious richness. If you’re making a chocolate cake and it doesn’t contain actual chocolate… please throw the recipe away. We don’t do that here.

Now let’s talk about the buttercream — specifically why Swiss meringue buttercream deserves its crown.

Unlike American buttercream, which is made by beating butter and icing sugar, Swiss meringue buttercream starts by gently heating egg whites and sugar over steam until the sugar dissolves and the mixture becomes glossy and smooth. That syrupy base is then whipped into a light, fluffy meringue before cubes of softened butter are added slowly. It transforms into the silkiest, creamiest frosting you’ll ever taste. It pipes beautifully, spreads effortlessly, and — the best bit — it’s not overly sweet. You actually want to eat it rather than scrape it off the cake.

I know it might sound like more work compared to American buttercream, but trust me — every extra minute is worth it for that glass-smooth finish and impossibly light texture. Once you start using Swiss meringue buttercream, you’ll never want to go back.

And since we’re all grown-ups here and no baking story is complete without honesty, let’s talk about the two problems that scare everyone the first time they make Swiss meringue buttercream:

➤ “My buttercream split!”
If your buttercream looks curdled, don’t panic — it simply means your butter was too cold compared to your meringue. Just keep mixing; the friction will warm the butter and it will come together beautifully. If it’s really cold, blast the bowl with 5 seconds of gentle heat from a hairdryer or sit it over a warm water bath for 10 seconds at a time and keep mixing.

➤ “My buttercream won’t come together — it looks soupy!”
That means the meringue was still too warm when you added the butter, so the butter has melted. Pop the bowl in the fridge for 10–15 minutes, then whisk again. Almost magically, it transforms back into that velvety cloud.

Once you master temperature (and it takes one attempt, truly), you’ll fly.

And here’s the best part: Swiss meringue buttercream makes cake decorating easier. Much easier. You don’t need professional skills — you just need the right frosting. Smooth sides become achievable. Crumb coats become satisfying. And the final finish? Pure joy.

So whether you're decorating your first cake or your fiftieth, this recipe is going to make you feel like the baker you’ve always wanted to be — confident, proud and willing to show off your cake instead of hiding it.

If you’re ready to make the smoothing-tool-down, happy-dancing, “oh my goodness I did THAT” kind of chocolate cake, grab your ingredients, clear some counter space and preheat the oven. We’re building a three-layer masterpiece that looks incredible, tastes even better, and showcases the star of the show — the silky Swiss meringue buttercream that changed everything.

‍