Brown Butter & Sage Mash Potatoes

I don’t think I’ve ever been so obsessed with an herb as I currently am with sage. It started innocently enough - a few crisp leaves fried in butter for a butternut squash pasta one evening — but since then, I’ve found ways to sneak it into everything. Sage butter with gnocchi andeven sage in brown sugar cookies (yes, really). There’s just something about its deep, earthy fragrance. Piney, peppery, and slightly sweet that feels both comforting and elegant. It’s the smell of warmth and the taste of quiet sophistication. And in this dish, brown butter sage mashed potatoes, it shines like the star it is.

Mashed potatoes are one of those simple dishes that everyone thinks they know inside out. Peel, boil, mash, done... right? But, like most comforting classics, the magic lies in the details. The kind of potato you use, whether you start them in cold or hot water, how you mash them, and what fats you fold in,they all add up to the difference between good mash and utterly perfect mash.

Let’s start with the potatoes. I always use a floury variety like Maris Piper or King Edward. They break down easily and soak up the cream and butter like a dream, giving you that cloud-like texture everyone secretly hopes for when they see mashed potatoes on the table. Peel them, chop them into even quarters, and start them off in cold water. This bit is crucial. It allows the potatoes to cook evenly from the inside out rather than shocking them with boiling water, which often leaves the outside mushy before the centre is cooked. A gentle, gradual heat coaxes the starches to behave, yielding fluffier mash.

While the potatoes bubble away, you can turn your attention to the real flavour anchor of this recipe: brown butter.

If you’ve never made brown butter before, let me paint the picture. You melt butter in a pan, and for the first few minutes, it’s just... butter doing its thing — foaming, bubbling, nothing too dramatic. But then, as the water cooks off, the milk solids sink to the bottom and start to toast. You’ll notice the colour shift — pale gold, then amber, then the perfect nut-brown hue. The smell at that point? Unbelievable. It’s like toasted hazelnuts, caramel, and holiday baking all rolled into one.

Now, imagine dropping a few sage leaves into that bubbling, nutty pool. They crackle instantly, releasing their aroma into the butter. It’s almost alchemical, the way sage transforms when it hits heat — that faintly medicinal sharpness mellows into something woodsy and warm, like a kitchen in the middle of autumn. The butter darkens just enough to catch all that toasty flavour without burning, and the sage crisps into these gorgeous little translucent shards that make you feel like you’re cooking something special (even though this recipe is just about as simple as it gets).

By the time your butter is perfectly browned and perfumed, the potatoes will likely be ready — tender, but not falling apart. Drain them well, letting the steam billow away for a minute or two. This step seems small, but letting them release excess moisture prevents soggy mash later on.

Now for the creamy part. Warm your double cream in a small saucepan before adding it to the potatoes. Cold cream would drop the temperature of your mash, making it gluey instead of smooth. Warm cream, on the other hand, blends right in and enhances that luscious, velvety finish.

Mash your potatoes however you like — a good old-fashioned masher works fine, but if you’re a texture perfectionist (and I am), passing them through a potato ricer or sieve makes them unbelievably silky. It’s a little extra effort, but worth every second. Once mashed, fold in a good pinch of salt — don’t hold back here. Potatoes crave salt the way caramel craves sea flakes. Taste as you go; the difference between flat mash and flavourful mash is often just a single pinch.

And then comes the best part — assembly. Spoon your creamy mash onto a serving dish, letting the peaks and swirls form naturally (no need for it to look perfect). Pour over that rich brown butter, letting it pool in the crevices like molten gold. Scatter the crispy sage leaves on top, maybe with a few flecks of sea salt for crunch. The smell alone will make you forget everything else in the room.

What I love about this dish is how something so humble — potatoes, butter, cream, salt — becomes luxurious with just one thoughtful twist. Brown butter turns up the volume, giving depth and richness, while sage adds complexity and warmth. Together, they make something that feels both familiar and indulgent.

It’s also surprisingly versatile. Serve it alongside roast chicken, seared steak, or a simple pan of garlicky mushrooms. It’s just as at home in a Sunday dinner spread as it is in a weeknight bowl when you want something cozy and satisfying. I’ve even had leftovers (when I’ve managed not to eat them all) turned into little potato cakes the next morning, fried in butter and topped with a poached egg — absolutely divine.

Lately, I’ve been finding myself drawn to these kinds of recipes — ones that are deceptively simple but feel like a small ritual. Browning butter, crisping sage, mashing potatoes slowly instead of rushing through it — these little acts of care make cooking feel grounding. And maybe that’s why I’ve become so obsessed with sage; it asks for a moment of attention. It’s not an herb you throw in thoughtlessly. It rewards you for slowing down — for noticing when it turns crisp, when the butter smells just right, when the kitchen fills with that toasty, herbal perfume.

There’s something quite meditative about it, really. I’ve been testing new dessert ideas lately (and sneaking sage into some of them), but this mash keeps calling me back. It’s a reminder that the best dishes aren’t always the showstoppers; sometimes they’re the ones that feel like home — simple ingredients, a few thoughtful steps, and a result that makes you close your eyes on the first bite.

If you’re making this for a dinner, I recommend browning a little extra butter — trust me, you’ll want to drizzle it on everything. Pour it over roasted vegetables, swirl it into soups, or toss it with pasta and Parmesan. Once you start cooking with brown butter and sage, it’s hard to go back.

So yes, I’m fully embracing my sage obsession. And if this dish does what I suspect it will, you might find yourself joining me — standing over a saucepan of bubbling butter, breathing in that nutty perfume, and wondering why you ever cooked potatoes any other way.

‍